New York's Friars
by John Burger

Reprinted with permission from
Catholic New York
June 3, 1999

Franciscans of Renewal blend evangelization and work with the poor


St. Adalbert's Church.jpg (35788 bytes)One recent Friday afternoon in front of the old St. Adalbert's Church in the South Bronx, two young men wearing bushy beards and gray religious robes greeted anyone who happened to be walking down the quiet stretch of East 156th Street. They switched easily between English and Spanish.

"How ya doing today? The church is open, if you'd like to stop in for a few minutes and say a prayer," they'd say. "Jesus is inside."

Some passersby accepted their invitation to the church, some said they were in a hurry. Any response was an opening for conversation, an offering of Catholic literature and a Rosary. With neighborhood kids on their way home from school, the men--members of the Franciscan Friars of the Renewal--found themselves tossing a ball and explaining why they wear such long Rosary beads hanging from their rope belts.

Those who went into the church found other friars and a few neighbors praying before the Blessed Sacrament exposed in a simple gold monstrance. The cool, subtly lighted, recently restored church was a place of calm and order amid the squalor and brokenness of the city. Even the bags of food, awaiting the weekly distribution to the poor, were lined up like soldiers in formation.

This was a vibrant Polish parish until the old generation moved out in the 1970s. The South Bronx decayed, crime rose, buildings burned. By the time the parish closed, eight members of the Capuchin Franciscan provinces of New York and New Jersey were contemplating a change in their own lives.

"There was a feeling among some of us that we would want to live our Capuchin commitment in a way we could imitate the work of St. Francis a little more closely, by working with the poor, living more simply, carrying out evangelization in a more direct way," Father Andrew Apostoli, C.F.R., superior of the Renewal Friars, told CNY. "We wanted to do more extensive preaching on a more consistent basis."Padre Pio Shelter.jpg (23411 bytes)

Explaining that they would follow the example of the Capuchin stigmatist Padre Pio of daily repentance and reform, they were dispensed from their vows in 1987 and formed a new community. They chose the name Community of Franciscans of the Renewal because they felt called to concentrate on their own personal renewal in Christ and the conversion of others.

"That's the Christian life--ongoing conversion and a call to holiness," said Father Robert Lombardo, C.F.R., superior at St. Crispin's Friary.

Father Bob, as Father Lombardo is known (in Franciscan tradition, the friars go by first names), was the first to move into St. Adalbert's, renamed St. Crispin's Friary after a 17th-century Capuchin beggar, the first saint to be canonized by Pope John Paul II.

The South Bronx seemed a perfect place to begin. The archdiocese allowed the community, which owns no property, to use St. Adalbert's. The first project started there, the Padre Pio Shelter for 18 homeless men in the basement of the school, is still filled every night. And next to St. Adalbert's rectory was an old burned-out six-story tenement, which the friars and Catholic Charities purchased from New York City for $1 and renovated as St. Anthony Residence, an SRO for 65 formerly homeless men.

"If you stood in the basement, you could see the sky," Father Bob, its director, recalled.

Being in a spiritual atmosphere has had a definite effect on the homeless men, said Father Terrence Messer, C.F.R., vicar of St. Crispin's. "They really leave the street behind," he said. "And they approach the friars all the time--the Catholics sacramentally, the others in a more general way." Many have turned their lives around.

CFR Street Evangelization.jpgThe school has become the site of several apostolates: a clothing distribution program; Alcoholics Anonymous meetings, St. Francis Center, which provides catechetical and athletic programs for youth in the neighborhood, and the St. Anthony's Free Medical Clinic, where nine volunteer doctors provide free vaccinations, physicals and blood work. Soon a free dental clinic will open.

The community grew rapidly. Its first superior, with the humble title "community servant," was Father Benedict J. Groeschel, C.F.R., whose high profile as an author and speaker helped attract new members. Father Benedict, archdiocesan director of spiritual development, has been host of a series of programs on Mother Angelica's Eternal Word Television Network, as has Father Andrew, also an author.

Cardinal O'Connor formally established the community as a public association of the faithful--a canonical term--in 1991, and last week formally raised its canonical status to a diocesan religious community, for which Rome gave its approval in March.

Today, its 50 members include six of the initial members. The others are Father Stan Fortuna, C.F.R., known for his "Christian rap music"; Father Glenn Sudano, C.F.R., novice director, and Father Robert Stanion, C.F.R., who works in ecumenical relations with Orthodox Christians.

In 1988, a group of women formed the Franciscan Sisters of the Renewal. Headed by Sister Lucille Cutrone, C.F.R., the four members live in Our Lady of Guadalupe convent on Bainbridge Avenue in the Bronx and collaborate in many of the friars' works.

Other friaries are Our Lady of the Angels for postulants, located in St. Adalbert's old convent; St. Felix in Yonkers; St. Joseph's for novices, in the old St. Joseph's Cursillo Center in Harlem, and St. Leopold for members studying for the priesthood at St. Joseph's Seminary in Dunwoodie.

Each house has a chapel with a picture of Our Lady of Guadalupe, the community's patroness, and a San Damiano Cross, depicting Christ's apparition to St. Francis and his command: "Rebuild my Church." "It reminds us of the need for renewal in the Church, and the fact that St. Francis started with himself, with his own conversion," Father Bob said.

The friars aim to live as simply and austerely as possible. Chapels, with hardwood floors, have chairs but no kneelers. "Actually, we have two kneelers," said Father Bob, pointing to his knees. Bedrooms are small, each containing a sleeping bag, crucifix, desk and a few books. Very few friars use a mattress, and air conditioning means an open window.

They cook the community meals, bake bread, wash their habits, clean and do whatever maintenance jobs they can. They're in the chapel at 6 a.m. for morning prayer, and during the rest of the day spend some four and a half hours in private and community prayer, including Mass.

Dear to their hearts is the cause of the unborn child. Members regularly pray outside abortion clinics, and some try to persuade women to keep their babies.

"A lot of men are drawn to our community because they have a strong inclination to support the Gospel of Life," Father Andrew said.

One friar went a step beyond prayer and persuasion. On May 13, 1995, Brother Fidelis Moscinski, C.F.R., a student at St. Joseph's Seminary, together with retired Auxiliary Bishop George E. Lynch of Raleigh, N.C., sat down in the driveway of the Women's Medical Pavilion in Dobbs Ferry, blocking cars from entering.

They knew they were risking severe punishment under the Freedom of Access to Clinic Entrances law, signed by President Clinton the previous year. But they felt compelled to save babies slated for destruction that day. They were arrested and charged with violating FACE and have since been waging a court battle based on the natural law that has edged the case toward the U.S. Supreme Court.

It's no surprise that the community has a close relationship with the Sisters of Life, the community founded by Cardinal O'Connor to promote the cause of life in 1991, the year he canonically established the Friars of the Renewal.

"We are great cheerleaders for one another," Mother Agnes Mary Donovan, S.V., superior, told CNY. "Pro-life work is a very active part of their work and witness, so they really are our brothers in that regard."

Underlying all the friars' work is the call to personal conversion. "Here I have the opportunity to die to myself by serving my brother tea or holding back from gripes," said Brother Elijah Ford, C.F.R., a seminarian from Manchester, England. "And out there, the poor will get me to heaven with their trusting spirit. They give me more than I can ever give them."

At the center of it all, any friar will tell you, is the Eucharist, which they present to young people in Youth 2000 gatherings around the country and which the people of the South Bronx come to adore every Friday afternoon in the old Polish church.

"That's what we're here for," Father Bob said. "To bring people closer to God."

"We Found God's Will"
by Michael Kelsey

Reprinted with permission from
Inside the Vatican magazine
June-July 2000
Robert Moynihan, Editor
Religious Life, pp. 52-55

A new group of Franciscan friars in the United States is "renewing the reform" and showing the way for a renewal of religious life in the 21st century.

Friars with Pope John Paul II (35788 bytes)


A new community of Franciscans split off from the Capuchins in 1987, committed to radical poverty, evangelization and pro-life witness. Here, John Paul II greets the Franciscan Friars of the Renewal.

This Jubilee Year, the 14-year-old Congregation of the Franciscan Friars of the Renewal (C.F.R.) will be expanding worldwide in an attempt to evangelize and care for the poor. Members of this small Franciscan community, born in the tough Bronx borough of New York City in 1987, have already taken steps towards forming friaries in Cannington, England, and Comayagua, Honduras. Both are set to open later this year. The friars have also been invited to Poland, Sudan and other US cities.

As the friars take on these new challenges, they plan to remain firm in their commitment to the Holy Father, an attribute that has helped define the character of the Congregation.

Though in existence since 1987, it was not until last year that the group received canonical approval as a religious congregation. Even so, the community is bursting at the seams. Dozens are flocking to join. They come anxious to put on the gray, cruciform habit of the C.F.R.s, that is, as is admonished in the investiture ceremony, to “put on the cross of Christ.”

Father Eugene Koch possessed a boyhood dream to join the Franciscan order, but when he discovered religious life was in crisis, settled for ordination to the diocesan priesthood. As a priest for 27 years in the Archdiocese of Newark, New Jersey, he served as both parish pastor and Vocations Director.

In 1998, Koch received permission to leave the diocese and enter the Community of the Friars of the Renewal, taking the religious name of Marius. His decision to join was grounded in the “absolute fidelity” toward the Church and the “authentic renewal” that he observed in the community.

He joins a handful of other older brothers who also entered the order after disappointing experiences in other areas of religious life. These men are the few gray-haired friars in the predominantly youthful order.

Although consisting primarily of energetic men in their 20s, the order already represents a fair cross-section of the Universal Church. Members of the order include men from England, Germany, and Kuwait, as well as American-born friars.

What is it about the Franciscan Friars of the Renewal that is so attractive? The overwhelming response, the friars answer, is its “authenticity.”

From the start, the C.F.R.s intended to return to the original vision of the Capuchin reformers and therefore to St. Francis of Assisi. Consequently, each friar assumes a simple life of prayer and lives by Divine Providence alone. Possessions are restricted only to the dress of the community, which consists of two thread-bare habits and a set of worn leather sandals. All food is received through begging. The community itself owns no property, and operates only out of buildings in which they are permitted usage.

Although not compulsory, most friars seek to set themselves apart from the secular world in an even more radical way. Commonly the friars grow long, bushy beards and shave their heads in order to attract attention to their un-worldliness. “That very attraction is something we want,” said Community Servant (Superior) Glenn Sudano C.F.R., “not for ourselves, but... because the Holy Father says the sharing of the Gospel is the ultimate act of charity.” This visibility is recognized as an effective tool in bringing about evangelization.

The friars wear long beards and their grey Franciscan habits as a sign of Gospel witness in the streets of New York.
One boy, upon observing Brother Sylvester Mann C.F.R. sidewalk counseling during a pro-life prayer vigil led by the Friars, approached him and asked, “Are you a Pope?”

Curious questions like this one about the friars’ appearance are not uncommon, but always find their satisfaction through a response which often brings the person closer to understanding Jesus and Christianity. “We believe that being a public witness is not only something the Holy Father desires,” affirms Father Glenn (by tradition Franciscans prefer to go by their first names only), “but we share in that desire.”

This adherence to the intent of the Holy Father is not an isolated one. The community views itself as having a special relationship with Pope John Paul II and anxiously tries to follow his will. “The community itself is a fruit of the pontificate of John Paul II,” Father Glenn believes.

Its very first friary was named for St. Crispin, a Capuchin Lay Brother who was the first saint to be canonized by Pope John Paul II. Father Benedict Groeschel C.F.R., and “Community Servant” (the order’s term for its leader) at the time the friary was named, acknowledges the reasoning behind the name. “No question, we wanted to honor the Pope,” he says.

Father Glenn is quite explicit in sharing the community’s esteem for the present pontiff: “We view the Holy Father as a saint, a hero, a prophet, a mystic, an intellectual giant, man of the century and would easily vote for his canonization and to give him the title the great.”

This admiration for John Paul II can be seen in their actions. The community thrives on fulfilling the will of the Vicar of Christ, particularly in fulfilling his call for the New Evangelization and responding to his encyclical, Evangelium Vitae.

“Clearly our lives are a response to the Holy Father’s call for the New Evangelization,” Postulants’ Director Father Bernard Murphy C.F.R. says. A major thrust of the community’s missionary work has been bringing others to Christ.

In addition to bearing witness through their dress, every act and every conversation is viewed as a direct pathway toward bringing someone closer to Christ.

Like the Holy Father, the Franciscans of the Renewal are quick to utilize the mediums of modern man in spreading the Christian message. “The New Evangelization,” said Father Glenn, “is not a new Gospel, but it is a new presentation; new wine, new wineskins. How do we mark it? How do we pack it? How do we present the Gospel in a way that young people today are able to understand it, perceive it, take it in and accept it?” The answer, he believes, is found in using the most current channels available to establish a connection with the culture of the 21st Century.

Father Benedict and Father Andrew Apostoli, C.F.R. both have authored a number of books and have appeared on numerous programs on Mother Angelica’s Eternal World Television Network. Father Stan Fortuna, C.F.R., also has been a guest on Mother Angelica Live and as a highly energetic former jazz musician, has produced a number of albums of Christian music under the jacket label of Francesco Productions. Much of this music targets and appeals to youth. His album SacroSong provided an alternative to gangster rap by offering an entire album of “catechetical rap” with lyrics based upon the Catechism of the Catholic Church. The album reached the number five spot on New Zealand’s rap music chart. Father Stan, who credits Karol Wojtyla, former bishop of Kracow, with the idea of catechizing through song, combines modern musical styles with messages that condemn the culture of death, promiscuity and drug use. The friars are anxious to use every available means to preach the Gospel to today’s hard-to-reach flood culture.

Adopting Pope John Paul II’s emphasis upon preparing youth as the leaders of the Church in the Third Millennium, the Franciscan Friars of the Renewal were quick to add Youth 2000 prayer festivals to their program of retreats and parish missions. An international movement operating out of Dallas, Texas, Youth 2000 seeks to revive the medieval practice of 40-hour devotions through retreats for teenagers. The idea exploded internationally after the 1989 World Youth Day in Compostella, Spain, where the Holy Father called for a decade of evangelization of young people leading up to the Jubilee.

The Congregation of the Franciscan Friars of the Renewal was one of the first communities to grab hold of the Youth 2000 program and incorporate it into their outreach. For them it was seen as a continuation of 16th century Capuchin practice that kept watch with Christ for 40 hours, commemorating the time Christ spent in the tomb. During this time of adoration, sermons were preached almost continuously on themes of repentance and festivity. Four hundred years later, few changes have been made and it remains effective in catechizing and renewal.

For several weekends a month around the United States and in foreign countries, young people gather in a makeshift chapel (formerly a gymnasium), to hear the friars deliver the Youth 2000 retreats. In the center, on a wooden pyramid, sits the exposed Blessed Sacrament as young people worship and sing songs of praise. Confessors line the outer walls awaiting young penitents who seek absolution for their sins. Throughout the weekend talks are given centering on vocations, morality and Catholic doctrine. The highlight of the weekend occurs Saturday night as the priest carries the monstrance throughout the room while young people reverently embrace the monstrance veil, in imitation of the woman of the Gospel whose faith in touching Christ’s cloak healed her (Luke 8:43-48). The whole environment is conducive for the young people to form a personal relationship with Jesus in the Blessed Sacrament.

Father Glenn sees Youth 2000 retreats taking on an important role in the New Evangelization and in passing on the Franciscan spirituality: “This apostolate would be very much of the spirituality and mentality of the Holy Father, but it is also very, very Franciscan. I mean young people singing, preaching, and the centrality of the person, the person of Christ in the sacrament, while at the same time confessions are going on. Here you have an environment which is very healing and very, very powerful.” Youth 2000 is effectively bringing teens and adults closer to Christ and His Church, so much so that Father Glenn concedes, “I can just see the Holy Father standing in the corner, arms folded, smiling, taking it all in and enjoying the young people singing...”

Youth 2000 retreats are providing a real service to the Church in bringing young people closer to God. The retreat challenges the teens to treat their Catholic faith seriously and to be open to the will of God in their life. Each retreat ends by asking those youth who may have felt called to the priesthood or religious life to come forward and receive a special blessing. Many young people regularly respond to this invitation.

A new novice with the Franciscan Friars of the Renewal, Brother James Plunkett, admits his motivation to join the community sprang from a positive experience he had on a Youth 2000 prayer festival led by the friars. Just as Youth 2000 retreats attract men to join the CFR’s, their prayerful pro-life work also attracts vocations.

Father Benedict Groeschel (center), flanked by Brother Fidelis Moscinski and Brother Elijah Ford, lead the rosary during a prayer vigil outside a US clinic where abortions are performed.
Responding positively to the Holy Father’s encyclical, Evangelium Vitae, the Franciscan Friars of the Renewal are in the foreground in the battle against the “culture of death.” A number of the friars came to the order with a considerable history of pro-life work. Father Conrad Osterhaut, C.F.R., presently Novice Director, spent an entire year in jail for a rescue in which he participated while a 3rd Order Regular at Franciscan University in Steubenville, Ohio. Similarly, Brother Fidelis Moscinski, C.F.R. came to the Friars of the Renewal with an extensive record of pro-life activity.

Brother Fidelis has been instrumental in initiating the friars’ prayerful presence at New York area abortion clinics on a regular basis. In fact, in between his seminary studies, Brother Fidelis frequently organizes and leads rosary processions through crowded streets, efforts that bring large crowds to pray at area abortion mills. As a result of efforts like these, a pro-life clause has been added to the community’s constitution, thereby widening its apostolates to incorporate efforts promoting life. “Through Brother Fidelis’ great interest and great love and (because) his heart is in this particular area,” observed Father Glenn, “he has greatly and directly affected the community and through his example and influence the friars continued to go out and lead these prayer vigils.”

Brother Fidelis gained greater recognition alongside Father Benedict and retired Bishop George E. Lynch of Raleigh, North Carolina, on May 13, 1995, when they were arrested for blocking the entranceway to the Women’s Medical Pavilion in Dobb’s Ferry, New York. Ordinarily the Franciscan Friars of the Renewal refrain from acts of rescue, opting instead to express the truth through peaceful acts of love like prayer and counseling, but “there have to be some willing to make the sacrifice,” said Father Conrad.

Once the police arrived at the Dobb’s Ferry clinic, all three religious were dragged into custody. Father Benedict complained that in jail “we were treated like garbage.”

“We were strip-searched three times within 24 hours,” Groeschel said. “And we were treated stupidly by the police. I knew these police all my life, for we were arrested in a town where I had been stationed all my life, nonetheless I was put in handcuffs.” Afterward, Brother Fidelis and Bishop Lynch were prosecuted for the rescue. Father Benedict was dropped from the case because he had no previous record.

A Catholic judge handed down an innocent verdict in the trial against Brother Fidelis and Bishop Lynch. Nonetheless, the prosecution relentlessly appealed and thus tried them for the same crime twice, which caused the ordinarily-unfriendly American Civil Liberties Union to file a “friend of the court” brief on behalf of the two religious. In the end, both men were exonerated.

Sister Dorothy Rothar, C.S.J. of the Helpers of God’s Precious Infants praises the order’s commitment to the unborn and to women for being “right on the front line” and “inculcating into their charism sidewalk counseling.” Sister Dorothy volunteers each week in training the order’s postulants in the art of sidewalk counseling. “It is important,” said sidewalk counselor, Brother Sylvester, who profited from Sister Dorothy’s training, “to always cooperate with the law. Approach the police first... the main thing is not to assert our rights but to fight for the rights of the unborn.”

With a close and personal relationship forged with the Sisters of Life, the Friars of the Renewal are active also in preaching retreats for post-abortive women.

Responding to Evangelium Vitae’s invitation to care for the vulnerable in society was an easy task for the Friars of the Renewal in that they were already hearkening to its call through their work with the poor.

Due to its high quality care for its residents, the C.F.R.’s Padre Pio Shelter is known on the streets of the South Bronx as the “Hilton for the Homeless.”

“The Holy Father’s emphasis on the dignity of every human person,” states Father Glenn, “has practical ramifications on how we serve the poor.” In great contrast to the barren friaries where the brothers live and eat, the shelter is lavishly decorated. Cushy couches, a fully operational entertainment system and an inviting piano line the shelter’s interior for the sole enjoyment of the homeless men who stay there. These comforts are present as if to attest to the dignity of the men whom society sometimes seems too eager to discard.

Residents at the Padre Pio Shelter eat meals in common at the kitchen table alongside the friars and volunteers, and use real ceramic plates rather than paper ones as a gesture that symbolizes their intrinsic value. “Its probably the most important thing in life (for these men) to be treated like human beings,” said shelter volunteer Archduke Geza Von Hapsburg. (The Archduke inherits his title from the family that produced Christendom’s many Holy Roman Emperors. Together with his wife, the Countess Elizabeth, and their small daughter, Isabella, the royal family of Hungry can be found regularly serving and uplifting the dignity of the men who frequent the shelter. “The Von Hapsburgs are known for being very close to the Capuchins,” volunteered the Archduke, and although the Friars of the Renewal are unable to lay claim to the title Capuchin, the Archduke conceded, “We love St. Francis and their interpretations of St. Francis.”)

The Franciscan friars of the Renewal stress pro-life work and evangelization. Here, Brother Francis Edkins prepares an icon of Our Lady of Guadalupe ‹ patroness of the unborn and of their order.
All eight of the brothers who came together in 1987 to form what became the Congregation formerly had been Capuchins. The order took much from the original Capuchin charism.

The Friars of the Renewal formed to rediscover the original flavor of St. Francis and incorporate it into the Franciscan apostolates of evangelization and direct work with the poor.

Brother Jack Rathschmidt, a Capuchin priest and Provincial General of the Capuchin order at the time of the split, compliments the C.F.R.s for areas in which he recognizes a true conformity with the legacy of St. Francis. “I think they are trying to live simple lives. I think they are trying to do hands-on work with the poor, not just talking about it, trying very hard to be prayerful. I admire all of that.”

The community’s steadfast determination to serve as a vehicle for the Pope’s intentions and its serious commitment to authentic renewal is outlined in Father Benedict Groeschel’s book, The Reform of the Renewal (Ignatius Press, 1990). It was written as a response to Father Benedict’s own experiences encountering the confusion generated by the post-Vatican II Church.

“The diseases of materialism, self-ism, cynicism and religious skepticism are so widespread and acute in our society and so pervasive in our culture,” Father Benedict writes, “that I do not believe there is any way other than personal conversion to work towards the reform of renewal.”

The bulk of the book considers ways in which the members of the Body of Christ can reform themselves so as to renew the Church. Father Bernard hails The Reform of the Renewal as “a must for our community,” in that the book illustrates the community’s whole charism built upon the foundation of “preaching and living renewal.”

In The Reform of the Renewal, Groeschel speaks of his community’s separation from the Capuchins. “Having experienced the vital force of a group of people drawn together for a common purpose, willing to risk their own good names and futures and strengthened in their loyalty to one another by the criticism they encountered, I am convinced that refounding can only be a painful but thrilling experience.”

“We understand that they had difficulties that were so acute to them and so painful to them that they felt they had to leave,” said Brother Jack, Provincial General of the Capuchin Order when the split occurred, “but we tried to create an environment in which they could stay in the order.”

The separation was painful. “It felt like a divorce,” confessed Brother Jack, “or at least it felt like what people who were divorced talked about, so that you kept looking for a place of reconciliation... but were just never able to make that kind of progress or step... so it was very painful to us, very upsetting to us, very confusing... eventually we just agreed that the rift between us was too big.”

The decision to leave the Capuchins was a difficult resolution for the eight original Franciscan Friars of the Renewal. It was only solidified after reflecting upon the life and words of Mother Teresa of Calcutta. This saintly nun felt called by God to leave her professed religious community in order to found the now world-renowned Missionaries of Charity. Mother Teresa’s example in leaving one order to begin a new one was as inspiring to the would-be Friars of the Renewal as were her words that explained her motives, “If you uncover the will of God, you must do it.”

“That’s what happened to us back in 1987,” recalls Father Bob Lombardo C.F.R., one of the original eight Friars of the Renewal, “We uncovered the will of God.”

Fourteen years later, the Congregation of the Franciscan Friars of the Renewal, like the Missionaries of Charity, are receiving world-wide recognition and branching out to other continents to evangelize and care for the poor.

Michael Kelsey graduated from Christendom College in 1999.
This is his first article for
Inside the Vatican magazine,
which can be contacted at www.insidethevatican.com or by calling 1-800-789-9494.